How would this show have changed if...

Kandiman
Moderator

Stupid Elvis Sandwich!

Posts: 537

How would this show have changed if... Dec 11, 2009 18:58:53 GMT

Quote

Post by Kandiman on Dec 11, 2009 18:58:53 GMT

(Feel free to link this to the One Tree Hill section, too)

I was just wondering... Chad Michael Murray turned down the role of Ryan Atwood to play Lucas Scott. How do you guys think that would've altered the two shows?

Personally, I think Chad is a better actor than Ben MacKenzie, but I can't imagine Chad as Ryan, nor anyone else as Lucas.

"You can't stand the idea that if a girl is choosing between two guys, she may not choose the romantic doofus who woos her with flowers and cheesy poems, you know? She just might choose the guy with the faster car or the bigger bicep or... the bigger joystick." ~ Joey Potter (Detention)

Peyton Sawyer
Administrator

.:Direction, beauty, meaning:.

Posts: 1,288

How would this show have changed if... Dec 11, 2009 20:19:09 GMT

Quote

Post by Peyton Sawyer on Dec 11, 2009 20:19:09 GMT

I do prefer Chad over Ben but I just don't think he could pull Ryan off. And no one else, at all, could possibly have played Lucas if you ask me.

I've seen Chad in DC and Gilmore Girls and although he's not quite as nice as Lucas is, he's still not the 'type' of guy that Ryan is.

Maybe it's just cos I think he's too scrawny, lol

A riddle wrapped in a mystery inside a bitch

True Love
Senior

Posts: 443

How would this show have changed if... Jun 23, 2010 17:43:41 GMT

Quote

Post by True Love on Jun 23, 2010 17:43:41 GMT

I agree on Chad being better then Ben, but Chad as Ryan.. I don't think so. Chad could never be that depressive, he's too hot. He could try, but no.. Ben is hot too, not hotter then Chad, but he has kind of face that can be in depression. LOL.